Table of Contents
Email marketing for your insurance agency isn’t just about sending policy reminders—it’s about building relationships, keeping clients engaged, and positioning your agency as their go-to insurance expert.
A well-crafted email campaign helps drive renewals, encourage referrals, and boost policy upgrades. The key? Emails that provide real value without fluff.
At Go Stack Media, we’ve used these exact email templates to drive clicks and boost conversions for our clients.
Our insurance marketing examples and templates lay out specific, actionable emails that your agency can use to nurture your client base and drive more traffic to your websites.
1. Welcome Emails For Your Insurance Agency
Why they’re important: A welcome email is your first impression—make it count! Clients who receive a welcome email show 33% more engagement than those who don’t.
It sets expectations, provides useful resources, and reassures clients they’ll make the right choice if they work with you.
Welcome Sequence Email Template #1
Subject: Contents inventory checklist and more
Hi and welcome! This guide is full of tips on how to lower your insurance premiums, how to inventory your contents, and includes a checklist to ensure you have the right coverage.
Download Your Checklist Here
How To Lower Your Insurance Premiums
1. Bundle your insurance: Many companies offer discounts if you bundle your home/renters and auto insurance together.
2. Improve your home security: This could include installing a security system, deadbolt locks, and smoke detectors. Some insurance companies offer discounts for homes with these features.
3. Make your home more disaster-resistant: This could include things like hurricane shutters, wind mitigation features, and flood mitigation measures.
4. Ask about discounts: Many insurance companies offer discounts for things like good credit, being a loyal customer, being claims-free, and having certain safety features in your home, tankless water heater, etc.
5. Review your policy and coverage limits with your agent annually: Make sure your coverage limits are accurate and reflect the current value of your home and belongings.
We’ll be back tomorrow with what you need to know before your insurance review.
Welcome Sequence Email Template #2
Subject: 5 Must-Know Tips for Your Next Insurance Review
Hi there and welcome to day two of your insurance review guide!
Whether you’re protecting your home, car, RV, or business, having the right insurance coverage is essential.
But how do you know you’re fully protected? Here’s a quick rundown of the top 5 things you should know for each type of coverage to help you feel confident in your insurance decisions!
[Button] Download Your Complete Checklist Here
For Home, Auto, Boat, RV, & Life Insurance:
- Home: Is your home covered for replacement cost? Don’t overlook high-value items!
- Auto: Do you have the right coverage for uninsured motorists? Rental car reimbursement coverage can be a lifesaver!
- Boat: Make sure your boat’s covered when it’s on the water AND in storage.
- RV: Know the difference between coverage when driving vs. when parked full-time.
- Life: Understand term vs. whole life and ensure your family is fully protected.
For Business Owners:
- General Liability: Covers your business for injury claims and legal fees. Don’t forget exclusions!
- Property Insurance: From building to inventory—know what’s protected against fire, theft, and more.
- Workers’ Comp: It’s mandatory in most states—protect your employees and your business.
- Business Interruption: Covers lost income if disaster strikes—essential for any business!
- Cyber Liability: Safeguard your business from data breaches and cyberattacks.
Have questions or are you ready to review your current coverage? Let’s chat and make sure you’re fully protected!
Welcome Sequence Email #3:
Subject: Meet our team
Introduce your team
2. Informative Emails: Stay Top-of-Mind Year-Round
Why they’re important: Clients trust businesses that provide consistent value. Informative emails build loyalty, improve engagement, and increase retention. These emails help educate clients while subtly reinforcing why they need your expertise.
Email Template
Subject: What should your home insurance deductible be?
Heading: Understanding Deductibles & How They Impact Your Premiums
Here’s a quick breakdown of how deductibles work and what you should consider:
Higher Deductible = Lower Premiums – Choosing a higher deductible means you’ll pay less each month, but more out-of-pocket if you file a claim.
Lower Deductible = Higher Premiums – Opting for a lower deductible means you pay more each month, but less if you need to make a claim. What’s Right for You? – If you have a solid emergency fund, increasing your deductible could be a smart way to save money on premiums. But if unexpected expenses are a concern, a lower deductible might give you peace of mind.
Pro Tip: Many insurance companies offer a vanishing deductible option, which reduces your deductible over time if you remain claim-free! Ask us if your policy includes this perk.
Have questions or want to explore your options? Let’s review your policy together and make sure you’re maximizing your savings.
[Schedule Your Free Policy Review]
Stay protected,
Your Agency Name
3. Monthly Insurance Email Updates Based on Seasonality
Why they’re important: Seasonal changes impact insurance needs, making them the perfect time to send timely updates. These emails ensure clients stay protected year-round and understand how their policies adapt to weather-related risks, travel, or home maintenance.
Seasonal emails also position your agency as proactive and knowledgeable, helping clients feel secure in their coverage choices.
Email Template
Subject: Winter Insurance Tips to Keep You Covered [You could also keep it light hearted and talk about electrical safety trips during the holidays]
Heading: Winter weather can bring unexpected surprises. Here’s how to protect yourself:
Homeowners Insurance: Check for ice damage coverage and review flood insurance if melting snow is a concern.
Auto Insurance: Review your policy’s coverage for winter accidents, and make sure you have roadside assistance.
Travel Insurance: Heading on a winter vacation? Ensure your policy covers cancellations and delays.
Questions? We’re here to help. Let’s review your policy together!
4. Policy Review Emails: Identify Gaps
Why they’re important: Policy review emails are essential for your insurance agency because they drive client engagement, retention, and revenue growth. By proactively reaching out to clients, you demonstrate that your agency is invested in their protection, building trust and long-term loyalty.
These emails create opportunities to identify gaps in coverage, upsell additional policies, and ensure clients aren’t overpaying or underinsured—directly increasing policy renewals and cross-selling potential.
Email Template
Subject: Could you be missing key coverage?
Heading: Smarter Coverage, Greater Peace of Mind
At Name Of Agency, we’re always looking for ways to help you protect what matters most. This month, we’re highlighting two key areas where the right coverage can make a big difference.
Homeowners Insurance: Are You Fully Covered?
Many homeowners are underinsured without realizing it. Rising property values, inflation, and policy changes could mean you’re not as protected as you think. Now is a great time to review your coverage and ensure your home is fully safeguarded. Check your coverage here.
The Hidden Gaps in Auto Insurance
Not all auto policies offer the protection you need in an accident. Are you covered for rental cars, uninsured drivers, or rising repair costs? A quick review can save you from unexpected expenses. See how your policy stacks up.
Your peace of mind starts with the right coverage. Click below to schedule a free policy review today.
Schedule Your Review
How To Include Calls To Action
A great email is useless if it doesn’t drive action. Here’s how to optimize your CTAs:
- Make It Clear: “Download Your Checklist” is more effective than “Click Here.”
- Use Buttons and Text Links: Buttons can increase click-through rates if the reader doesn’t click the text link.
- Offer Value: “Get a free policy review” sounds better than “Schedule a call.”
Start Using These Emails Today!
Email marketing doesn’t have to be complicated. Whether you’re welcoming new clients, educating your audience, or prompting policy reviews, these insurance email marketing examples will keep you top-of-mind and drive real engagement.
Get monthly email templates delivered to your inbox.
Email Marketing For Insurance Agencies FAQ
How often should I send emails to my clients?
The frequency of your emails depends on your audience and the content you’re sharing. Generally, sending one to two emails per month is a good starting point. This keeps your agency top-of-mind without overwhelming your recipients. Always monitor engagement metrics to find the optimal frequency for your specific audience.
What types of content should I include in my emails?
Your emails should provide value to your clients. Consider including policy updates, industry news, tips on insurance-related topics, special offers, and client success stories. Personalizing content based on the recipient’s interests and policy type can also enhance engagement.
How can I improve my email open rates?
Improving open rates starts with crafting compelling subject lines that grab attention. Make sure your subject lines are clear, concise, and relevant to the recipient. Additionally, personalizing emails, sending them at optimal times, and ensuring your sender name is recognizable can boost open rates.
What are the best practices for ensuring compliance with email marketing laws?
To comply with laws like the CAN-SPAM Act and GDPR, always include an easy way for recipients to unsubscribe from your emails, provide a physical mailing address, and avoid misleading subject lines. Obtain explicit consent before adding someone to your email list and keep records of this consent.
How do I measure the success of my email marketing campaigns?
Key metrics to track include open rates, click-through rates, conversion rates, and unsubscribe rates. Analyzing these metrics can provide insights into what’s working and what needs improvement. Additionally, A/B testing different elements of your emails, such as subject lines and content, can help refine your strategy.
